K&G’s Holiday Buyer’s Guide 2012

Keen and Graev's Holiday Buyer's Guide 2012

The holiday shopping season is once again upon us! We are continuing our tradition of posting a Holiday Buyer’s Guide. Every item on our Holiday Buyer’s Guide is not only something we already own, but something we truly recommend and give our seal of approval. That’s what makes our guide unique, and hopefully useful to our readers. If you have any questions, please ask us and we’ll do our best to point you in the right direction towards the perfect holiday gift.

Find our entire Holiday Buyer’s Guide 2012 after the break, and please share your picks for the top gifts this season in the comments!

Nintendo Wii U

Wii U

The Wii U just launched, but we’ve been working hard to play and review as many games as possible. We highly recommend the Wii U, and will detail more in our upcoming review of the console itself. If you can somehow get your hands on a Deluxe Set it is completely worth it for the additional storage space and copy of Nintendo Land.


New Super Mario Bros. U – Wii U

New Super Mario Bros. U Box ArtThe Super Mario ‘World’ feel is finally back in Mario’s first adventure on the Wii U. New Super Mario Bros. U shines in glorious HD graphics for the first time, and offers multiplayer that will keep you laughing and cursing at each other for stealing new power ups all day long. We feel the difficulty is just high enough to challenge veterans, but forgiving enough (especially with the new help tools) to guide new players towards the fun.

Utilizing the new GamePad will allow one player to take on the role of a booster who can place platforms, slow enemies, and assist the player to the finish. This is a fantastic way for parents to get involved with kids, or to find new an innovative ways to quickly speed through levels.

Check out our New Super Mario Bros. U review where we gave the game a 4.5/5!


Scribblenauts Unlimited for Wii UScribblenauts Unlimited – Wii U, 3DS

Maxwell is back once again with his magic notebook. This time he has a backstory and a reason for progressing through the 40 levels and relatively open side-scrolling world. The goal of the game is to gather Starite to free your sister of a curse she is suffering all because you were a naughty little prankster.

The goal of the game is simple: Travel around levels solving people’s problems and performing general problem-solving tactics to obtain pieces of Starite. To accomplish this task, you have your magic notebook — cleverly integrated into the Wii U GamePad. If you have never played a Scribblenauts game before, the gist of it is you can write almost anything that isn’t a proper noun and it will appear in the game. For example, if I see a bug I have to kill I can write “fly swatter”, but it’s a lot more fun to write “gigantic fire-breathing plant” and have my horrific creation take care of the problem — although I may want to include “Friendly” as to not kill myself.

Scribblenauts Unlimited is fun, whimsical, and a real playground of adventures. The fun isn’t in playing the game to beat it, but seeing how creative you can be. And for the first time ever, friends can join in the fun via multiplayer and take control of your creations.

Our Scribblenauts Unlimited review is currently in progress.


Call of Duty Black Ops 2Call of Duty: Black Ops II – Xbox 360, PC, Wii U, PS3

Despite the incremental development we’ve seen from the Call of Duty franchise over the years, every once in a while it’s not a bad idea to check back in and see how things are progressing. We skipped Modern Warfare 3, but decided to dive back in and give Black ops 2 a try. We’re glad we did.

Black Ops 2 doesn’t disappoint with the polished gun-play we expect from CoD. The multiplayer levels are much better than those found in the original Blops, and there’s a mode for just about everyone. The perk system has been overhauled to provide a much more balanced experience, and killstreaks have been replaced by scorestreaks in an effort to get people playing for objectives instead of just kills.

Note: Xbox 360 has the most people playing online, and the PC crowd is excellent as well.

We gave Black Ops 2 a 4/5 in our review.


XCOM: Enemy Unknown – PC, Xbox 360

XCOM: Enemy Unknown is a turn-based tactical strategy game with sim elements. The gameplay is carried out in missions launched from a static base of operations where the player is in charge of managing resources and upgrades. During these missions you rank up your units, stop enemies from destroying objectives, capture aliens to bring back for interrogation, and obtain tech.

XCOM really requires a lot of thinking. Utilizing elevation, cover, aim stats, and getting the most out of your turn is really important — especially on higher difficulties. Gameplay changes depending on the units you are using as well.

Fans of the XCOM series will enjoy this modernization of the series, and the strategy-minded gamer can find many hours of enjoyment.

We have an impressions post for a deeper look at XCOM: Enemy Unknown.


Borderlands 2Borderlands 2 – Xbox 360, PC, etc.

We squeezed every last hour of enjoyment possible out of Borderlands 2. We beat our first playhthrough in just over 60 hours, then went through on NG+ and added another 60. The gameplay itself is a quasi-RPG FPS. The goal is to play through the story while developing your character and, most importantly, finding loot. Character development is done by leveling up and allocating talents into trees which allow you to play, ideally, three different ways. Loot is abundant. Like most action RPG’s, loot spews forth from every monster killed and it’s up to you to identify what is an upgrade.

Brutally difficult on higher levels, it can be a great idea to bring along a friend. Co-op works flawlessly — that’s how we played over 120 hours together via Xbox live.

We also -highly- recommend the ‘Captain Scarlett and her Pirate’s Booty’ DLC which adds another 20 hours of play, lots more quests, and an area to the game that is even better than any area in the original content.


Dishonored Game


Dishonored – Xbox 360, PC, PS3

Dishonored is a first-person stealth action game reminiscent of Thief, and somewhat of Half-Life 2. There’s also a Bioshock feel with special powers like plagues of rats.

You go through levels with open-ended objectives, having multiple ways to complete them. You’re an assassin of sorts, seeking revenge on your marks. During the course of the game you can choose to make legal or illegal decisions to accomplish these goals, and your decisions weigh in on the direction the game takes.



Nintendo 3DS XL

Nintendo 3DS

Last year we highly recommended the Nintendo 3DS to our readers. In fact, we love the 3DS so much we wrote a 3DS Starter’s Guide that is still very applicable today.

Now the Nintendo 3DS XL is out, and it’s bigger and better than ever. The size makes holding it much more comfortable, and the screens are larger to further enhance your enjoyment. We definitely recommend having one for any dedicated 3DS gamer.



Paper Mario: Sticker StarPaper Mario: Sticker Star – 3DS

Paper Mario: Sticker Star is a step back in the right direction, especially after Super Paper Mario. The RPG mechanics are gone — no leveling up — but the combat system has gone back to the turn-based combat system of previous games. Instead of equipping badges, you use stickers which are essentially disposable 1 use badges — attacks, etc.

Despite being on the fence at first, the game turned out to be a ton better than expected.


Adventure Time: Hey Ice King! Why’d you steal our garbage?

You might have to be a fan of the series to truly enjoy Adventure Time because it captures the aesthetic and brings. If not a fan, you may not get a lot out of it. It’s very reminiscent of Zelda 2 because you walk around on an over-world and you can get attacked randomly by enemies who appear as a shadow — they event look like the enemies on Zelda 2 — and you enter into a battle screen.

The entire game plays out like an episode of Adventure Time, and fans of the series wouldn’t have the game play any other way.


Harvest Moon 3D: A New BeginningHarvest Moon 3D: A New Beginning

If you’ve played one Harvest Moon, you already know the gist of A New Beginning. Although saying it’s a farming simulator is understading things quite a bit, it is essentially a game about planting and harvesting crops. However, A New Beginning does a lot of amazing things with customization that make the game a ton of fun.

Players can design the layout of the town and their farm, giving it an extra personal touch. In this harvest moon there are also many additional types of animals — even Alpacas!

Multiplayer allows players to trade items, and bring animals between local and online play via the new Nintendo Network. If you’re a fan of Harvest Moon, A New Beginning is a must buy.


Mists of Pandaria – PC / Mac

Most of us will agree that Cataclysm was an awful expansion. Mists of Pandaria, however, does a lot to correct the mistakes Blizzard made in their previous World of WarCraft expansion.

Coming up in the 5.1 patch is the ability to upgrade gear using Valor points. This gives players a reason to continue playing regular content, and provides a way to continually improve.

Daily quests are prolific, but the Tillers are an enjoyable Harvest Moon style of quest — and much of the items are actually worth obtaining in many of the dailies.

Having played through much of the content already, Mists of Pandaria has definitely proven itself to be worth the investment.


Skylanders Giants Starter PackSkylanders Giants – Wii U, Xbox 360, Wii, etc.

Skylanders is a toy/video game hybrid. You place little figures on a portal and they transport into your game. They level up, gain new powers and abilities, collect hats, complete challenges, etc. When you lift your figure up from the portal it retains all of its info so if you go over to a friend’s house you can just place your figure on a friend’s portal and jump right in to co-op or versus battles with your own character.

Skylanders Giants is a completely new version of the game, but allows you to bring in and play your Skylanders from the original.  The Giants themselves are extremely neat to play with, stomping around and smashing baddies.

We enjoy the game, but recognize it does not do a whole lot to differentiate itself from the original.  If you loved the first, you’ll love Giants.  If you were only mildly impressed, then consider skipping this rather expensive hobby.  Nevertheless, it’s sure to excite kids and man-children the same!


Sonic & All-Stars Racing Transformed

Sonic is back with his friends in another All-Stars Racing game!  Sonic & All-Stars Racing Transformed brings in a lot of the more interesting SEGA franchises this time.

All of the awesome features introduced by Nintendo to the Mario Kart franchise have been shamelessly taken and improved upon.  Flying is completely free-form, boats drive on the water, and cars completely transform to meet the needs of the track.  Compared to Mario Kart where these transformations didn’t mean a whole lot, in Sonic Racing the changes are drastic and knowing how to drive/pilot in every scenario is important.

There are several challenges during the campaign that make the game more than an arcade racer, and there is local and online multiplayer as well.

The Wii U version (which we own) allows one player to use the GamePad as their own screen, givng the second player the entire TV without needing to split-screen.  We think this is a great feature.



We will continue to update our Holiday Buyer’s Guide throughout the shopping season!

  • Having played AC3 and Far Cry 3, I think its pretty safe to say that both these games would be a hit under the christmas three.

    X-Com is a great game. Anyone just remotely fans of tactical turn based shooters should check it out.

    Dishorned i’m not so sure about. It felt a bit too easy, and I did it all the sneaky way on hard difficulty. And the strange part, it only got easire as the game moved along because you get all these super powers, but the enemies does not change that much.

    Borderlands 2 is a great game as well, and is 50% off at steam atm!

  • We didn’t have any plans to pick up Far Cry 3, but we’ll be getting AC3 a little closer to (or at) Christmas time. I hear both are good.

  • Thanks again for taking the time to create this. A couple of questions please good sirs.

    1. How do you feel feel the toughness is on the WiiU controller. Is it something that an 8 year old could mess up if dropped? I would assume they built it for younger kids, but wanted to ask. It just “looks” like it could get messed up pretty easy.

    2. Is Skylanders NOT on your list for a reason. Both of my boys mention the game every now and then, but neither has shown much excitement when they see it in stores. Still not sure if should be a possible Christmas idea.

    Other notes: Xcom is fantastic and I’m really enjoying MoP. I’m finally getting past a big deadline I have on the 28th, after that both these games are getting a workout!

  • I think the WiiU is not a good idea to have on your list. I know you have it but there is not enough out for it yet plus the games that should be signature like the zombie one are getting horrible reviews. Give it 6 months as any console in the past has proved it needed to let the games catch up and the deals to show up.

  • @Howdy Doody: I still need to talk to Graev about Skylanders. I’m 90% sure it’s going to be added to our list today. If they absolutely loved the original, then Skylanders Giants should be fun for them. If it was only a mild success, hold off because it is very similar.

    The Wii U GamePad is deceptive. It looks heavy, but it is SUPER light. If dropped on carpet you should be fine. The screen support both stylus (identical to 3DS) and finger touch. Make sure no one touches it with messy hands and you should be perfectly fine. It’s intuitive, and even easier to use than a 3DS.

    @Goom: We really, really enjoy the Wii U — a million times more than we did the Wii when it launched. ZombiU reviews are mixed, not horrible. For every horrible review there is at least one glowing positive. We haven’t played it enough yet to review it, but we will very soon.

    The Wii U plays games like Batman, Assassin’s Creed, Mario, Sonic & All-Stars racing, Nintendo Land, and more, and does a great job.

  • @Kenng: Yeah, PS2 is a lot of fun. We didn’t add it to the Buyer’s Guide because everyone can play it for free (then spend money optionally on cash shop stuff).

    I can’t play currently because when I do my entire computer locks up and I have to hard reset. I can’t figure out what is causing it to happen only with PS2.