My in-depth PotBS Beta Impressions

According to the Official Pirates of the Burning Sea website the NDA has been lifted as of approx. 11:30AM PST.

I guess I’m one of the few out there who waited for the NDA to actually drop officially. They announced to the testers that the NDA would drop on the 3rd but that doesn’t mean people should jump the gun and get their reviews of the beta up at the stroke of midnight. Wait for the public press release before you break the NDA folks. It’s been common practice for over a decade in MMORPG’s to make a public press release when the NDA is lifted. Anyway, yes I was obviously in the PotBS beta and I would like to share with you my in-depth impressions of the beta and explain my thoughts on each of the broad aspects of the game. Obviously this isn’t a review of the game itself nor will I be scoring it in any way. I simply want to tell you all what I liked and what I disliked about what I saw over the past few months.

In addition to this review of my beta experience I also invite you to check out my Captain’s Blog that I write over on the Vault Network. It will rehash a lot of what has been said here since, well, I wrote it also but nevertheless it’s a good read with a neat parchment background. I’ll be updating that blog usually once a week.

How does the game look? When I first began testing the game, it was several builds from where it is now. The game still felt the same but it was definitely lacking the polish of a release build. They have since polished the game immensely and I can say, confidently, that PotBS is a beautiful game with some of the best water effects I have ever seen (all in Dx9 too!). Avatars are real looking yet they still provide that fun “avatar” look that sets them apart from what the real people would look like back in the 1700’s. There are still a few issues to be worked out with shadows and some articles of clipping issues. The ports themselves are beautiful and alive. On the open see though I feel the world was really dumbed down in order to make traveling quicker.

Pirate Clothes Some animations in the game are still a bit wonky. Characters have a very peculiar way of running that takes some getting used to. In their defense though, in many MMOs, running feels slightly odd at first. Combat animations are top-notch. In PotBS, land battles are definitely a lesser form of gameplay because the majority of the game is spent out on the waters of the Caribbean. Ship sailing in both instanced and open sea feels like you’re truly sailing a ship. When sword fighting with an enemy NPC, you engage in what feels like a real sword clashing fight. Like many aspects to the game, land combat has evolved slightly since the start. In early beta it felt like it lacked any form of challenge because enemies would drop in just a few swings of the sword. However in this latest build, players will truly have to overcome their opponent’s balance in order to land hits. Quite well done, in my opinion. Aside from the battles, little time will actually be spent on land. Ports are not much more than quest hubs.

Ship Combat Where PotBS shines is definitely at sea when doing battle against another ship. This is the heart of the game here folks. Ship combat is very simple: get in range, turn your ship to line your guns up, and press the space bar to fire. Get your enemy’s ship to zero “health” and it sinks. Sounds too simple, right? Where skill comes in is most definitely the wind and maneuvering your ship. Knowing your enemy is also a key to ship combat. Many ships are weaker in certain areas than others. If you’re going up against an enormous Ship of the Line, it would be foolish to sit there and take a full blast to your broadside. Use speed to your advantage and out maneuver the SOL by coming up behind him. Using various types of ammunition you can also out class your opponent. Wrecking sails, for example, is a great way to disable an enemy. Don’t forget about boarding. It’s the simple process of getting close to another ship and grappling – then it becomes a land battle. FLS got it right with ship combat but it may not be apparent to everyone right away. A huge bonus? Levels play absolutely zero part in the combat equation. Levels simply unlock the abilities to use better ships and give you more abilities.

Pirates of the Burning Sea offers a lot of customization to both character and ship. Character creation options are plenty, though not quite the City of Heroes range they wanted. Ships can also be customized with sail patterns, ship and sail colors, a name, and different weapon outfitting. Character’s can visit a tailor shop in most ports to change the appearance of their character instantly (and currently for free in the beta). Although the sail patterns are only permitted through approval via a vote on the message boards it’s definitely worth doing because it adds a new level of personality to a hunk of floating wood. Characters need only worry about a few pieces of equipment and most of them are for looks. This is definitely not a game of gear grinds. Skill is everything.TalentsCharacters are also able to customize their skills and abilities. Each level you are given 1 point to allocate into your class skills which act as a form of talent tree. You unlock abilities farther down the line as you get the prerequisites out of the way. These abilities are very important because they offer your character things such as faster reloads, more defense, more offense, the ability to cloak on the open sea, ad hoc PVP, etc. You are also able to train in your swashbuckling skills which will give you more abilities to use in land combat. Some of these abilities are leaps and bounds better than others but they’ve done a nice job of explaining each one. Make sure you read them and pick the ones that sound powerful – they are.

You’re probably wondering what everyone at this point wants to know. Where’s the downside to PotBS? It’s not a perfect game and many aspects of gameplay do require more work. The biggest issue facing the game right now is missions/quests. This is the fastest way to level, and believe me it’s pretty fast, but it’s also downright dull. Currently there are only so many different “types” of missions and you will experience most all of them from the very first port. It brings a whole new meaning to the “go here, kill X” quest formula when nearly every encounter appears to look the same. The land missions become repetitive and look almost identical. Each villa or jungle is laid out nearly identical to the last and you get a strong sense take they took some pretty big shortcuts when designing these missions. There are also only so many different ways you can instance the ocean before water starts to look like.. well.. a whole lot of water. You’re going to burn out quickly and have very little fun if you approach PotBS from a quest grind to level direction. I advise you now – don’t. At least until they add more variation or develop this system more.

World Map I’m also not a fan of the way everything in the game is instanced. If you see a ship out on the ocean and engage it you are taken into a private encounter or instance where only you and the ship(s) you’re fighting can see each other (and often the scenery around you is completely different than it was on open sea, heh). I guess it might be one of the best ways to do it given how big ships are and how virtually enormous their game world would have to be in order to accommodate the ship battles of everyone, but it still bothers me when I’m sailing the open sea and there’s these two ships circling each other to indicate someone is fighting there. To add more on top of this I do not like how you are teleported to mission battles both land and sea. You simply talk to the port authority figure, click the mission you want to do from that port, and poof!… you’re suddenly in the middle of this instance doing the quest. For me it hurts immersion and takes away from the experience. If FLS is smart they’ll take this idea and use it to their advantage. Instancing content allows for much more intimate encounters between the players and the content the developers intend to portray.

Boarding Combat Avast ye me hearties! There be PVP in this game yo ho ho! That’s the biggest draw of PotBS for me and probably for a great many of you out there. You want to fight for the Pirate Nation or bring glory to the crown of France? It’s that sense of pride in your nation that will add lasting appeal to this otherwise shallow ocean. The map is a true layout of the Caribbean and each nation has a few ports which are considered uncap’s. You won’t be able to take over the newbie starting port and you won’t take the capital port either. You will however, be capable of gaining enough influence in a port to turn it over into contention. At that point a big red circle appears on the map showing where PVP is enabled. This is where the meat of the PVP in the game will take place because outside these red circles there’s not much else you can do to get attacked. If your nation is on a roll you’ll be able to take a large portion of the map in your conquest. There are also other options for PVP which include the ability to go into a “battleground” type instance with objectives. I’m hoping this will see more attention when the game goes live because right now it can be somewhat a ghost town. PVP needs some work. Since so much of the game is instanced already, would it hurt to allow us to attack and lay siege to a port instead of just influencing it?

I want to talk about the PvP a little bit more; infact I want to include some PvE mechanics in this too. This isn’t a game without risk like some of you might be used to. In PotBS your ship can sink if you’re defeated in PvP AND PvE. When your ship sinks, depending on the ship, it may be lost forever. Ships have durability points and once depleted they are destroyed for good. Let’s say your ship has 2 durability and you die once. You’re sent back to the nearest port for repairs and your ship now has a durability of 1. If you get sunk again your ship is destroyed and you are stuck at port given the newbiest of vessels until you procure another. This is where Pirates are vastly superior to the other nations. Pirates have the ability to capture ships when they do battle. You can actually disable and claim another player’s ship or an NPC ship. This makes being a Pirate so cool – you can stock up on ships for free instead of having to purchase them from auction. The risk in PotBS is high and so is the reward. Even if you’re not a pirate you can claim some of your opponents cargo. The seas are a dangerous place.

Auction HouseThe economy in PotBS, probably one of the most talked about aspects of the game so far, is completely player driven. Everything from a barrel of rum to cannon shot will be made by players. I like a player driven economy because it adds another side to the game and in turn adds more lasting appeal. There’s even a class dedicated to this side of gameplay which tells you something: they want their economy to be a huge asset to the gameplay. It’s really well thought out and their approach works. It is however, like missions, a little disappointing if you’ve built yourself up thinking it’s going to be something more. There’s always talk of “build your factory and have your workers make this for you” but you never, ever, see your factory or your workers. In fact the structures you build are nothing more than little icons in a tab on the interface. You macromanage your structures without ever getting to see them and that was a huge disappointment for me. I wanted to see my buildings, open a shop or house, and have a true “place” in a port. Turns out I only have a “slot” in my interface to call my own.

I built myself up to think a lot of things about the game that won’t come true. I had originally thought the game would be big and open like a normal MMO and that I could get with a few of my buddies and just sail out toward the horizon and come across enemy ships or island to search and plunder. I’m slightly disappointed to find that the open world is more of a birds-eye “map negotiator” type experience. With instances and teleporting to missions the sense of exploration is 100% missing from PotBS – that could hurt them. It’s not bad… it’s just not what I had hoped for when I originally envisioned sailing the burning sea. I do however think that their PVP system and the way you engage in nation-wide pvp has merit. Ambushing players who sail into contested waters will be a blast.

It’s always interesting to look at how a developer works with their testers to perhaps gain some insight into how they will handle situations at release. FLS was a pleasure to test for and their GM staff was always helpful. Their servers were a bit rocky at first but I think they have their stability fixed. The game uses SOE’s patcher which I abhor for its slow download speeds but there’s not much we can do about that. Overall I am looking forward to seeing how FLS does as they set course into uncharted waters.

Overall, Pirates of the Burning Sea has a solid foundation from which to launch a very new and unique approach to MMOs. There is a lot of creativity put into making sure this experience is unique. Even with the faults that I find in the game, I am still accepting of them for now because of how different FLS has tried to make this game. I am absolutely excited about what PotBS can become and I can’t wait for launch. With great potential comes the great chance for disappointment and I plan to blog about all sides of PotBS for my readers.

  • Wow, nice writeup. Couple of questions, though:

    Can I start at one point and navigate to another port, sailing the whole way? Or am I just tele-port-ed (ha ha) to somewhere near that port?

    Are there weather effects? Do turbulent waters or high winds affect battles or missions? Can you be becalmed (no wind) and what do you do then? Can you take your opponent’s wind by staying upwind of them, making it hard for them to maneuver?

    How close to the wind can you sail? In fact, I’ve seen nothing so far about how realistic sailing is. I’d expect better ships to sail closer to the wind than other ones. Do ships go faster when the wind is abeam? Is tacking and jibing handled automatically?

    So much about sailing depends on the wind and the weather. I hope PotBS hasn’t scrimped on either. All the screenshots I’ve seen, though, makes the game look perpetually (oops wrong company) sunny and calm.

  • On the open Sea (semi zoomed out map negotiator feel) you can sail. It’s not what you might think though. It’s not like running around in a normal MMO (Like say running from Neriak to Freeport) I’ll take a few screenshots to show what I mean.

    While sailing you’ll see other player ships and NPC’s but it’s like sailing on a huge scaled back map. It has its own charm in a way but lacks in the “exploration” feel.

    There are no weather effects such as rain that make sailing more difficult. There are winds though which are usually static in one direction that will cause you to have to know how to sail into them and out of them to get the most out of your sails. There are upgrades to your ship and skills you can obtain that make sailing with the wind better. There’s also no ability to take the enemy’s wind unfortunately.

    You have the ability to raise and lower your sailes (up arrow and down arrow) and the ability to turn left and right (right and left arrow). The tacking and jibing is technically done automatically but you can control the sailability through the use of the arrow keys.

    If you sail directly at the wind you’re not going to move much at all. Your sails will deflate. Some ships are better at sailing against the wind, etc. You go much faster if you use currents on the open sea and if you sail with the wind at your back.

    Sailing is semi realistic. There are some times that I question if a ship could have really done what it did but overall it has a lot of believability.

    Believe me when I say the last thing you want to do is get stuck in the open ocean without a current or the wind in your favor… it could be a PITA to have to make your way across the Caribbean against the wind.

  • Makes me wonder if there is a sea battle simulator which accurately simulates real naval battles from the sailing era? I know there is a game series called “Age of Sail”, but I wonder.

    There’s a bunch of yacht race simulators that take real conditions, sails, hull design, everything into account, but yachts are not fighting ships.

    Also, I wonder if PotBS limits its ships in time, or if you can get super fast ships like clippers ๐Ÿ™‚

  • You can get very fast ships with 4 guns that will sail circles around any other ship and you can get enormous 101 gun ships of the line which are massive and very very slow but will obliterate the fast ships in one blast.

    You can upgrade your hull and your sails and you can of course buy ships with better everything (or steal someone else’s if you’re a pirate).

    PotBS does a great job at the Ship combat and sailing, there’s no doubt about that.

  • “exploration is 100% missing from PotBS”.

    Yep. You nailed it. Its still fun, but that’s exactly it.

    The Open Sea is travel, not exploration. I too was hoping that at least with the “go intercept some pirates/smugglers/bad guys” missions, for example, that you’d well, have to actually go exploring to find them or their hideout rather than have the Longboat Coxswain whisk you away to a cove full of their ships or their beachfront hideaway.

    More time consuming, yes, but more immersive.

  • “Also, I wonder if PotBS limits its ships in time, or if you can get super fast ships like clippers :)”

    PotBS’ ships are from between 1660 and 1740, with rare exceptions where plans from that era weren’t available (read: Galleons). Some ship plans are a bit more recent, but they were “retrofitted” as they would have been in the appropriate time. There’s a 3D Steering Committee in place to offer advice for community shipwrights, and they have a watchful eye on period-appropriateness of ships that are to be included in the game.

    So, no clipper for you ๐Ÿ˜‰

  • That’s a very good point Cameron. Right now the game isn’t something that will rock the industry. It’s a good game with some limitations.

    I definitely recommend you give the open beta a try though. The game does have some charm that lures you in. ๐Ÿ™‚